Friday, July 08, 2011

On Casey Anthony

Innocent and not guilty are two different concepts. Without cause of death and direct forensic evidence, the prosecutors put forth a lot of circumstantial theories. I watched quite a bit, and I don’t think they made the case. The jury had to decide based on the evidence, not how unlikeable Anthony was.

Personally, I cannot understand how someone could go a month without notifying the authorities, or even worse, hit the party circuit. But, there are all kinds of reactions to stressful situations.  I do not like Casey Anthony, and I am certainly not alone.  However, my personal dislike does not invoke the death penalty.

Unfortunately, the press – Nancy Grace, in particular – made the trial into both a personal quest and a ratings bonanza. I found that extremely disgusting. I also think that the roving crowds of outraged citizens need to quit taking justice in their own hands, and put some faith – or at least respect – in our jury system. 
 
Maybe she’s guilty. Maybe not. In any case, the decision is made, and we cannot change it. Further, we are not above the law.   Are we to go out with torches and pitchforks whenever we disagree with a jury verdict?

I used to believe that all trials needed to be in the public eye.  With the sad state of the press today, I'm slowly changing that belief.  Several talking heads, including Nancy Grace, spent months, if not years, working to convict her on the air.  While we celebrate our freedom of the press, perhaps we should not feed it raw meat.

Someone said that the strength of our legal system is not in how we treat the best of us, but rather in how we treat the worst of us.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

It is bizarre (or actually not) how obnoxious Nancy Grace has been and still continues to be. She refuses to call Casey Anthony anything other than "Tot Mom" which is pretty much the tactic of most gutter press: pick a memorable short name because you disrespect your readership and viewers as too dumb to remember anything else. Beware sound-bites - they are the bad smell of arrogant egos.

As you know, I totally agree with your point of view. Personally it seems extremely abnormal behavior for any mother not to be spending every possible waking moment - at least for the first realistic few months - looking for their missing child in a state of abject distress. Abnormal perhaps to the point of having some form of can't-face-the-loss personality disorder or chronic grief that manifests itself as "party girl" behavior. Maybe? Probably not though. Well, let's hope it isn't anyway because if Caylee did die accidentally and what her mother did was go crazy to the point of burying the body with her mind in a state of total meltdown then it's almost too horrible to think of if she had been convicted of murder.

Anonymous said...

I have to admit that I haven't followed the Anthony case much but we have the same reactions here whenever a heinous crime's committed. The media whip up a frenzy amongst the public who then seem to think they have a right to decide guilty or not without having heard the real evidence (or lack of it), despite what the jury decide.

Trial by media is a very dangerous thing.

Tira M. said...

Nicely written. These were my thoughts exactly. I DVR'd the trial and watched it every day. I haven't watched Nancy Grace in a long time. I can't stand how one-sided her arguments are. As far as the trial, the prosecution didn't prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt in the eyes of the jury, so that means she isn't found guilty. As much as I feel like she isn't innocent, there is no proof that she is guilty of murder. Many people I know are outraged at the verdict, and see it as proof that our justice system is flawed. I'm glad that this jury didn't allow their emotions to get the best of them, and they simply looked at the facts and judged her based on the evidence presented in the trial. Hopefully, she didn't commit these terrible crimes, but if she did, i'm sure she won't escape justice forever. Life has a way of sorting these things out.

Brennig said...

Not an expert, but I have read here and there about this case. It seems a peculiar outcome, especially given some very strange behaviour on the mother's part. In Scotland, which has its own legal system, they have a verdict of 'Not Proven'. Sometimes I think that's a good alternative outcome.